CERVICAL CANCER AND THE HUMAN IMMUNODEFICIENCY VIRUS : A REVIEW cl in ical

Globally cervical cancer is one of the commonest cancers in women. It comprises approximately 12% of all cancers and is the commonest cancer in women in developing countries. The most recent compilation of global data indicates that an estimated 490 000 new cases of cervical cancer occur annually worldwide and nearly 80% of these are in developing countries, where screening programmes are not well established and are poorly organised. Cervical cancer is the leading cause of cancer death among women. It is estimated that 270 000 women die annually from cervical cancer, 85% of them in low-resource nations.1-3 In Africa, cervical cancer comprises 23.3% of all cancers in women.4 According to the South African National Cancer Registry (NCR) data, the lifetime risk for the development of cervical cancer in 1998 was 1 in 26 for South African women and 1 in 21 for black South African women.5 These are believed to be minimal rates, as the registry publishes only data collected from the pathology laboratories and is not a population-based cancer registry. HIV/ AIDS poses a severe threat to global health. In addition, the HIV epidemic has hit hardest in regions of high prevalence of cervical dysplasia and cancer. The HIV epidemic in South Africa is one of the worst in the world. The prevalence of HIV among South African women attending antenatal clinics in 2006 was 29.1%.6 With improved access to antiretroviral therapy, women are expected to live longer as the risk of death from opportunistic infections decreases. It is assumed that the incidence of cervical cancer and the prevalence of precursor lesions will increase, especially in countries that lack well-organised cervical screening. However, this remains to be seen.

Cervical cancer and its precursor lesions are caused by infection with the human papillomavirus (HPV).The human papillomaviruses are part of the Papovaviridae family of viruses and consist of tightly coiled, circular, double-stranded DNA with about 8 000 base pairs in their genome.The papillomavirus is an obligatory intranuclear virus that must infect mitotically active cells to institute infection.Within the cervix HPV most commonly infects the mitotically active transformation zone at the squamo-columnar junction, which explains in part why HPV is associated with both squamous and glandular neoplasia.Over 100 different HPV types have been identified, of which approximately 30 -40 infect the anogenital tract.HPV viruses of the anogenital tract are divided into 'low-risk' and 'high-risk' types depending on their ability to produce neoplasia. 7,8There are a variety of opinions on how the human papillomavirus types should be classified.One commonly used classification (Munoz) published in 2003 divided them into 15 oncogenic (high-risk) types (HPV 16, 18, 31, 33, 35,  39, 45, 51, 52, 56, 58, 59, 68, 73, 82) and 12 nononcogenic (low-risk) types (HPV 6, 11, 40, 42, 43, 44,  54, 61, 70 and 72, 81 and CP6108). 9The vast majority of HPV viral infections are cleared within 14 months in women with competent immune systems.However, through a complicated cascade of events some infections evade the immune system, becoming a persistent infection.Persistent HPV infection is the first step towards cervical dysplasia and cancer.The E6 and E7 proteins of oncogenic HPV types are known to facilitate the degradation of tumour suppression proteins.
² With the loss of suppression of these oncogenes, the cell cycle is disturbed.Factors that may increase the risk of persistent infection and cell dysregulation include immune suppression, cigarette smoke, multiple sexual partners, age of first intercourse, hormonal birth control and possibly other sexually transmitted infections such as Chlamydia. 7,8lobally cervical cancer is one of the commonest cancers in women.It comprises approximately 12% of all cancers and is the commonest cancer in women in developing countries.The most recent compilation of global data indicates that an estimated 490 000 new cases of cervical cancer occur annually worldwide and nearly 80% of these are in developing countries, where screening programmes are not well established and are poorly organised.Cervical cancer is the leading cause of cancer death among women.2][3] In Africa, cervical cancer comprises 23.3% of all cancers in women. 4According to the South African National Cancer Registry (NCR) data, the lifetime risk for the development of cervical cancer in 1998 was 1 in 26 for South African women and 1 in 21 for black South African women. 5These are believed to be minimal rates, as the registry publishes only data collected from the pathology laboratories and is not a population-based cancer registry.
HIV/ AIDS poses a severe threat to global health.In addition, the HIV epidemic has hit hardest in regions of high prevalence of cervical dysplasia and cancer.The HIV epidemic in South Africa is one of the worst in the world.The prevalence of HIV among South African women attending antenatal clinics in 2006 was 29.1%. 6With improved access to antiretroviral therapy, women are expected to live longer as the risk of death from opportunistic infections decreases.It is assumed that the incidence of cervical cancer and the prevalence of precursor lesions will increase, especially in countries that lack well-organised cervical screening.However, this remains to be seen.

HUMan PaPillOMaViRUS
RElaTiOnSHiP BETWEEn HiV anD HPV ViRUSES vironment of HIV-negative women. 12HIV may increase the risk of HPV replication or transcription by a direct viral-viral interaction. 13,14V oncogenic types 16 and 18 account for 90% of high-grade intraepithelial precursor lesions in HIV-negative women. 15However, data from a variety of studies in southern Africa show a diversity of HPV types.
In Zambia Professor Parham in a 150-women study found that 98% of HIV-infected women harboured at least one type of HPV (85% had a high-risk HPV type), with a median of four types per participant.HPV 52 was the most common. 16A study in South Africa of 148 HIV-infected women showed similar results, with 95% of the women harbouring HPV, a median of three HPV types per participant, and 85% of women having one or more oncogenic HPV types (HPV 16 accounted for 30%, followed by 35 and 53). 17Data from other developing countries in South America and Asia also show a large diversity of oncogenic HPV types (including 16 and 18) in addition to other types, such as 33, 35, 52 and 81. 18,19Which oncogenic types are causing cervical cancer in HIV-seropositive women in Africa still needs to be determined.Recent results from a study in Kenya indicate that the prevalence of HPV 16 was similar in HIV-seropositive and HIV-seronegative women with invasive cervical cancer. 20veral studies have shown that invasive cervical cancer in HIV-positive women tends to present 10 -15 years earlier than in their HIV-negative counterparts.
In addition, HIV-positive women with invasive cervical cancer have a much greater degree of immunosuppression than HIV-positive women without cervical cancer.Women with CD4 counts below 200 cells/µl are significantly more likely than HIV-negative women to have advanced-stage disease at presentation. 21,22V-positive women have higher rates of HPV and cervical abnormalities than HIV-negative women.A study by Denny et al. 10 of 400 untreated HIV-infected women who underwent HPV DNA testing, cytology, colposcopy, histology and a CD4 count every 6 months for 36 months showed that 68% of women were positive for high-risk HPV DNA, 35% had low-grade squamous intraepithelial lesions (LSIL) on Pap smear, and 13% had high-grade squamous intraepithelial lesions (HSIL) on Pap smear.
Abnormal cytology and the presence of high-risk HPV DNA were strongly correlated with low CD4 counts and high viral loads.A study by Yamada and co-workers in Kenya 23 demonstrated cervical HPV infection in 17% of HIV-negative and 49% of HIV-positive women.LSIL was found in 6.9% HIV-negative and 21% of HIV-positive women, and HSIL in 0.6% of negative and 5.8% of positive women.HSIL was strongly associated with high-risk HPV types and low CD4 counts.
A study by Cardillo et al. 24 showed HIV viral load to be significantly higher in women with cytological abnormalities.This study concluded that the degree of immunosuppression may contribute to the development of a squamous intraepithelial lesion, but once the lesion is established, disease progression may not be affected by CD4 counts.A Finnish study 25 of 153 HIV-positive women followed up for a mean of 5.6 years showed 33% to have cervical neoplasia.The risk of cervical neoplasia was not associated with decreased CD4 counts, duration of HIV infection or use of antiretrovirals. 25e vast majority of LSIL regress spontaneously in immunocompetent women.HIV-positive women with LSIL have a lower rate of regression and more tendency to progression.In a study by Massad et al., 26 progression of cervical dysplasia was observed in 14% of HIV-positive women compared with 7% of HIV-negative women.Regression to normal was noted in 43% of HIVpositive women and 66% of HIV-negative women.In a study by Ahdieh et al., 27 cervical dysplasia regressed in only 45% of HIV-positive women after a median of 2.7 years, which was significantly lower than the regression rate in HIV-negative women.
In summary, HIV-positive women tend to have a higher prevalence of HPV, more HPV types with multiple oncogenic-type infection, more HPV persistence and a higher prevalence of cytological abnormalities than their HIV-negative counterparts, and tend to present at an earlier age with cervical cancer.
Prevention of cervical cancer can be primary or secondary.Primary prevention modalities include adopting safe sex practices and HPV vaccination.Secondary preventive (screening) techniques include cytology, visual inspection of the cervix and HPV testing.

PRiMaRY PREVEnTiOn
Sexual abstinence is the only way to completely prevent transmission of HPV.Transmission of HPV appears to be fairly easy.9][30] The rate of HPV transmission may be lower in circumcised males. 31The efficacy of condoms in preventing transmission of HPV is uncertain.One small study 32 showed a decrease in the rate of genital HPV infection from 89.3/100 patient-years to 37.8/100 patient-years in women reporting 100%

cERVical lESiOnS in HiV-POSiTiVE WOMEn
PREVEnTiOn OF cERVical cancER HPV in HiV-SEROPOSiTiVE WOMEn condom use.Consistent use of condoms may increase HPV clearance and increase the rate of regression in HIV-negative women. 32The impact of condom use on HPV transmission in HIV-positive women is unknown.
Two vaccines that protect against certain types of HPV have recently become available.Cervarix (GlaxoSmith-Kline) produces antibodies to HPV types 16 and 18 while Gardasil (Merck) produces antibodies to HPV types 16, 18, 6 and 11 (the latter two cause genital warts). 33,34verseas trials have suggested that these two vaccines reduce the incidence of cervical cancer significantly, as it has been estimated that approximately 70% of cervical cancer is caused by HPV types 16 and 18.However, cervical screening will still be necessary as 30% of cervical cancers are caused by HPV types other than 16 and 18.Also, it will be required for women who have not received the vaccine.
The prevalence of HPV types in southern Africa as discussed above may differ from those overseas, so data from HPV vaccination studies elsewhere may not be as helpful in southern Africa.The safety and efficacy of the preventive HPV vaccines in HIV-positive women also remains to be determined, as it is not known whether a sufficient antibody response to the vaccine will be obtained.Ideally girls should be vaccinated before risk of exposure to either HIV or HPV.In addition, HIV-positive women have a higher rate of infection with multiple HPV types, which may impact negatively on the efficacy of current vaccines against HPV types 16 and 18.Another type of HPV vaccine that is still in the early phases of testing is the therapeutic vaccine, to be given to women already infected with HPV to block the E6 and E7 oncogenic proteins and thus prevent progression. 35

ScREEninG FOR cERVical cancER
Cervical screening programmes are traditionally based on cervical smears.In countries with well-organised cytologically based cervical screening programmes (such as Mexico, Columbia and many developed nations), the reduction in the incidence of and mortality from cervical cancer has been dramatic. 36,37A cervical smear-based screening programme is a three-step (visits) approach, viz.women have a smear taken at a clinic, women with abnormal smears then have to be referred to a colposcopy centre for colposcopic biopsy to confirm the cervical results, and then, once confirmed, women have to be referred for treatment of the lesion.
Cytology is associated with a significant false-negative rate.The estimated sensitivity is only 50 -60% for detection of cervical intra-epithelial neoplasia HSIL or greater in routine screening settings.9][40][41] Despite these limitations, cervical cytology remains the only proven method for reducing the incidence and mortality of cervical cancer in large-scale population screening.South Africa's cervical screening programme includes three smears in a lifetime at 10-year intervals starting at age 30.If this could be undertaken effectively, it is estimated that 66% of invasive cervical cancer would be eliminated. 42Although South Africa's screening programme was launched in 2000, it has yet to be implemented on any large scale.A cytologically based cervical screening programme requires a reasonably well-functioning health care system.Unless good follow-up and referral mechanisms are in place, women may be lost to follow-up at any one of these steps.Accessibility of colposcopy and treatment of cervical dysplasia is currently very limited in the South African public sector.
Visual inspection of the cervix with acetic acid (VIA) has been investigated as an alternative to cytology in low-resource nations.VIA is a simple procedure involving swabbing the cervix with 5% acetic acid and after a few minutes observing any change of colour of a normal pink cervix to white.The white areas may represent cervical dysplasia.The normal columnar epithelium is dark pink to red.If in the area of the mitotically active transition zone, the white areas may be indicative of cervical dysplasia and can be treated with cryotherapy at the same visit. 43The convenience and relative simplicity of VIA makes it preferable to the Pap smear in many resource-limited settings, because it does not require the client to return to the clinic for her results.
Assessment of VIA accuracy in large cross-sectional, randomised controlled trials in developing countries in HIV-negative women indicates that its sensitivity in detecting high-grade precancerous lesions ranges from 66% to 96% (median 84%), its specificity from 64% to 98% (median 82%), its positive predictive value from 10% to 20% and its negative predictive value from 92% to 97%. 44,45The major strengths of VIA include its simplicity: there is no need to prepare the patient; it can be taught to nurses, nurse-midwives and other health workers in a short space of time; it costs less than other approaches in routine use; there is real-time availability of results (results are available immediately, eliminating the need for multiple visits in most cases, and reducing loss to follow-up); there is potential for immediate linkage with investigation/treatment; and no specimen transport, expensive laboratory equipment or highly trained personnel are needed.
The major limitations of VIA include low specificity (generally less than 85%) -a considerable number of women who test positive do not have disease, resulting in excessive diagnosis and treatment, and unnecessary anxiety; lack of standardised methods of quality control (there is no permanent record of the test that can be reviewed later); training and competency of screeners are difficult to evaluate; its ability to detect endocervical lesions is limited as a result of difficulties in sampling and visualising the endocervical canal, as well as less experience among readers in recognising glandular cell lesions; and tests to follow up women who have been treated are lacking.4][45] VIA has mostly been evaluated as an once-in-a-lifetime screening test, and its performance in periodic screening has not been assessed.Validation in HIV-positive women is required.
The vast majority of HPV infections will clear spontaneously, especially in women below the age of 30 years, so HPV DNA testing has good negative predictive value but less good positive predictive value.Other disadvantages of HPV DNA testing are the cost, dependence on reagents currently produced by very few commercial manufacturers, and low specificity in younger women.HPV testing usually requires sophisticated laboratories with highly trained personnel, often not available in low-resource nations.7][48] A rapid HPV test for use in low-resource countries, the HPV Digene Fast Test, has recently been developed.It obviates the need for sophisticated laboratories, and one study has shown good results. 49Further investigations in this regard are required, especially in HIV-seropositive women.
Various combinations of cytology, VIA and HPV testing have been described, but the best method of screening in both HIV-positive and HIV-negative women has yet to be determined. 50,51 colposcopy has confirmed the Pap smear cytology result of a high-grade lesion with histological results of CIN 2 or CIN 3, treatment of the lesion is required.
Treatment can be done via a variety of methods.A very efficient outpatient procedure requiring only local anaesthesia is called either LEETZ (loop electrosurgical excision of the transition zone) or LEEP (loop electrosurgical excision procedure) biopsy.The procedure uses a thin electrified wire to remove the lesion up to 7 mm in depth from the transitional zone.LEEP or LEETZ is a very effective procedure in non-HIV-seropositive women, with a success rate of 80 -85%. 44,52However, a study in Soweto indicated that in HIV-seropositive women in South Africa the failure rate may be as high as 50% (defined as incomplete margins on pathological specimens). 53Close follow-up is required in HIV seropositive women and additional procedures may be needed.
More definitive treatment includes the cone biopsy.This is an effective mode of treatment, but requires referral to a centre with a skilled gynaecologist, inpatient admission, and operating room availability. 52yotherapy can be done after the VIA procedure, during the same visit as discussed above, eliminating the anxiety and loss to follow-up that lengthy delays in follow-up visits cause and reducing the inconvenience of work, child-care and transportation issues.The procedure needs a consistent supply of nitrous oxide with a cryotherapy gun and probe.Freezing the lesion requires application of the gas for about 2 minutes and the patient should come for follow-up visits at 6 weeks, 6 months and 12 months (Gosbeck Parham, personal communication).Recurrent lesions found after VIA are referred for LEEP.Cryotherapy means that there are no pathology results, so it is not known what lesion was treated.Large lesions and lesions spreading into the cervical canal cannot be treated with cryotherapy and need to be referred for LEEP. 43sterectomy is reserved for refractory cases of carcinoma in situ that cannot be treated appropriately with the above methods.

OTHER TREaTMEnT MODaliTiES
Micronutrients, vitamins (vitamins A, E and C) and antiretroviral agents (gancyclovir and cidofovir) have not shown any positive effect in the treatment of cervical dysplasia and should not be recommended. 52As HPV infection is an immunomodulated disease, there is some hope that HIV antiretroviral therapy (ART) would improve regression rates and prevent the progression of cervical dysplasia as ART has improved the outcomes of patients suffering from Kaposi's sarcoma. 54However, findings of reversal of cervical dysplasia in HIV-positive women receiving ART have been quite controversial, with disparate results. 55,56Reports indicate that antiretroviral drugs may improve outcomes in cervical dysplasia in HIV-infected women.However, other cohort studies show that ART has no effect on cervical dysplasia. 57As HPV is already integrated into the host genome and oncogenic gene changes are already occurring, ART given after the lesions have been developed may be too late to change the course of the HPV disease progression.Larger prospective cohort studies are needed to assess the effectiveness of ART in preventing cervical cancer in women with HPV-HIV coinfection.
With the effective ART roll-out in South Africa many women will survive opportunistic diseases, and cervical cancer screening needs to be on the agenda of HIV/ART

TREaTMEnT OF cERVical DYSPlaSia
clinics.With the overwhelmed public sector obstetrics and gynaecology services in South Africa, limited accessibility, long waiting periods between Pap smears, colposcopy and LEEP, disjointed care and loss to follow-up between departments, cervical cancer screening and treatment need to be available and offered in HIV clinics as an integrated service.